Reasons why the Supreme Court ruled in favor Hubert Webb and other co-accused.

1. Jessica Alfaro, the star witness was working at that time she revealed her story as a NBI asset, one who earned her living by fraternizing with criminals so she could squeal on them to her NBI handlers. She had to live a life of lies to get rewards that would pay for her subsistence and vices.

2. NBI handlers were making their own investigation about the Vizconde massacre case, and since Jessica Alfaro hanged out at the NBI office and literally lived there, it is possible that she heard evidentiary details and gain access to the documents.
   

3. She said that Webb proposed twice to his friends (Gatchalian, Fernandez, Rodriguez, Lejano, Ventura, Estrada and Filart) the gang-rape of Carmela who had hurt Webb, (allegedly Carmela was not faithful). And all his friends consented twice to the plan including Alfaro’s boyfriend. But when they got to the house of Carmela only Webb, Lejano, Ventura and Alfaro entered the house. The others just stayed outside waiting including her boyfriend Estrada, which was inconsistent with the plan.
   

4. Norman E. White Jr., the security guard in the Pitong Daan Subdivision confession was inconsistent with that of Alfaro. The security guard also did not notice a policeman (Biong) the one who was tasked to clean the crime scene upon the order of Webb.

   Lauro Vizconde said that Carmela spoke to him about a suitor who she rejected but this was inconsistent with Alfaro’s testimony that they (Carmela and Webb) had an on-going relationship.

5. The prosecution said the Webb and Carmela were sweethearts but none of Carmela’s friend came forward to talk about their relationship. It is impossible not to notice Hubert Webb because he is a son of a politician. And MR X - the cause of all the trouble who was said to be the lover of Carmela that caused Webb to harm her. No one in the family or friends of Carmela knew about him.
   

6. If the court will accept the Alibi of Webb that he was in America during the commission of the crime. All the other co-accused will be acquitted because according to Alfaro Webb led the crime.

SC said “Will the court send the accused to spend the rest of their lives in prison on the testimony of an NBI asset who proposed to her handlers that she take the role of the witness to the Vizconde massacre that she could not produce?”